Plan to abolish NSW stamp responsibility might create extra issues than it solves


All property purchasers in NSW might quickly be exempt from paying stamp duty on new property purchases underneath a brand new authorities proposal.

Whereas the plan might seem to be a good suggestion to some, I’m not likely satisfied it is going to be as broadly helpful as many individuals assume.

What’s stamp responsibility?

Earlier than we talk about the proposal and it’s advantages and hindrances, let’s first make clear what stamp duty really is.

Stamp duty is a “one off” tax imposed by state and territory governments on sure transactions.

StampIt may fluctuate relying on the state or territory, and could also be referred to as stamp duty, switch responsibility or common responsibility.

When shopping for a property, the purchaser genrerally should pay stamp duty on the transfers of land or property to their title.

Relying on the worth of the property you’re shopping for you may be taking a look at forking out tens of hundreds of {dollars} in stamp duty on the time of settlement, however sure concessions and exemptions could also be obtainable.

And because it’s a state-based tax it could actually additionally fluctuate vastly from state-to-state relying on each the acquisition value and what you might be buying.

What’s the NSW authorities proposing to do?

Based on CoreLogic information, the median home value for Sydney is $993,927, which implies a purchaser would wish to pay a $40,065 upfront stamp duty on their buy.

However underneath the brand new NSW authorities proposal, we might see stamp duty phased out and replaced with a new tax instead.

NSW Treasurer Dominic Perrottet’s plan would see a purchaser, who plans to stay in the home they buy, have the choice of both paying stamp duty up entrance or a smaller annual tax on land value.

Land tax was beforehand solely levied on traders and commercial property house owners, however the brand new proposal would apply for all householders, together with owner-occupiers.

What number of further persons are we speaking about right here?

Properly, in line with the latest census statistics, 64.5% of individuals in NSW personal the property they stay in both outright (32.2%) or with a mortgage connected (32.3%).

That interprets to a whopping 1.68 million Australians to which the proposed authorities plan would apply.

Because the plan continues to be solely a proposal we don’t have all the main points but, nonetheless the NSW Authorities intends to “seek the advice of” regarding this proposal till March 2021.


Picture from the Australian Financial Review

Why is the NSW authorities proposing to abolish stamp responsibility?

On the face of it there are two causes.

  1. The State Authorities is conscious that stamp duty tax is quite widely loathed.
  2. Perrottet claims his plan, which might see consumers capable of opt out of stamp duty for a land tax instead, would go some option to reduce the monetary barrier inhibiting some consumers to buy a brand new residence.

LandtaxIf the plan have been to go forward, he suggests the transfer might tempt extra would-be purchasers to make the leap and purchase a property, underneath the guise that as a result of they’re capable of keep away from the upfront lump-sum fee, they’re subsequently saving cash.

However whereas it might appear tempting to abolish it, given stamp duty charges earned the NSW authorities round $7.4 million within the final monetary 12 months, it could actually’t merely disappear.

We all know how authorities budgets work…the stamp duty earnings that will be misplaced would must be changed with an analogous quantity of earnings (or probably extra) from one other supply.

I can think about they’d be happier with an annual earnings of a property tax not topic to the ups and downs of the property cycle and paid by each house owner and investor relatively than the lumpy stamp duty they’re presently getting.

That is notably related following current property market volatility the place the federal government is ready to earn far much less earnings from stamp duty taxes than normal as consumers halted plans amid the coronavirus pandemic and financial downturn.

So is abolishing stamp responsibility in NSW a good suggestion?

Certain, on the floor it seems just like the proposed modifications may very well be a good suggestion.

However I don’t assume it’s so simple as it sounds.

Not surprisingly the proposal to scrap the unpopular tax has garnered a lot of curiosity from many so-called property consultants and insiders.

Stamp DutyAnd so they have very conflicting views on whether or not the brand new proposal is a good suggestion.

And my view?

Having been across the block a few instances, I’m cautious of a plan the place the federal government intends to switch one tax with one other at a time when it’s already made clear that it requires extra income.

Certain, the proposed modifications would give the federal government a gentle stream of earnings, however there appears little doubt that a property buyer would end up paying more tax in the long term.

Actually, after a decade, the quantity somebody might pay in land tax would probably surpass the quantity they’d have coughed up in the event that they’d opted for stamp duty within the first occasion.

Canstar’s infographic (under) exhibits that complete land tax on a $700,000 property might quantity to $1,970 for the primary 12 months, earlier than shortly leaping to a complete of $10,227 in 5 years and $21,469 in 10 years.

By the fifthteenth 12 months, the property proprietor could have paid $33,860 in land tax funds, which far exceeds the one-off stamp duty price of $26,835 – by an additional $7,025.

Likewise, the whole land tax on a $1 million property may very well be round $2,600 within the first 12 months, skyrocketing as much as a complete of $28,527 in 10 years.

Because of this by the point the proprietor has lived within the $1 million property for 15 years they’d have paid $4,822 greater than in the event that they’d paid a one-off stamp duty payment.


Supply: Canstar

Now I can see what has pushed the NSW authorities to make the proposal.

It might be a pleasant little earner for the NSW authorities wouldn’t it?

Perhaps not a lot for its property consumers and sellers, and even the market as an entire.

So whereas plenty of business our bodies consider the proposed change is a good suggestion as a result of it’ll allow extra individuals to purchase and promote property, I’m not so certain.

The proposal might create a few issues for the NSW property market

Drawback one: It might put us vulnerable to a two-tiered market

Whereas the total particulars aren’t but obtainable, it’s potential that if a purchaser opts to pay the annual property tax as an alternative of the unique stamp duty prices, after which on-sell his residence, future purchasers may also be pressured to pay the annual land tax on this identical property.

This might create a really difficult two-tier property market the place some properties would come onto the market burdened with an ongoing tax, whereas others wouldn’t, making some extra enticing to consumers than others.

Drawback two: It might create a lull available in the market

Stump DutyWithin the short-term the proposed modifications might trigger a lull available in the market whereas individuals wait to see if they’ll save on stamp duty earlier than they buy their subsequent residence.

Actual Property Institute of New South Wales (REINSW) CEO Tim McKibbin advised that the proposal really has the potential of adversely affecting the housing marketplace for months as potential consumers take a ‘wait and see’ method.

“Optimistically, this gained’t happen till mid-next 12 months on the earliest. Till then, we run the danger of consumers sustaining a wait-and-see method,” he mentioned.

Drawback three: It might push property costs up in future

Whereas a property market lull may very well be a brief time period downside, in the long run consumers would seemingly use their further gathered financial savings to purchase a costlier residence.

When consumers have extra money to spend, competitors usually will increase which might in flip push property values up additional.

Drawback 4: It doesn’t really assist first residence consumers

At present, many first residence consumers are already eligible for a spread of incentives, together with stamp duty exemption.

So whereas Perrottet claims his proposal would go some option to reduce the monetary barrier inhibiting some consumers to buy a brand new residence, it’s unlikely to assist first residence consumers into the market in any respect.

And isn’t that a part of the issue with our housing market? Inaccessibility for brand new first-time consumers?

The underside line…

Until there may be much more satan within the element that we’re not but conscious of, I’m not satisfied the proposed abolishing of NSW stamp duty will actually profit any of us.

Now’s the time to take motion and set your self for the alternatives that may current themselves because the market strikes on


For those who’re questioning what’s forward for property you aren’t alone.

You possibly can belief the crew at Metropole to offer you route, steering and outcomes.

In “fascinating” instances like we’re presently experiencing you want an advisor who takes a holistic method to your wealth creation and that’s what you precisely what you get from the multi award successful team at Metropole.

For those who’re looking to buy your subsequent residence or funding property right here’s 4 methods we can assist you:

  1. Strategic property recommendation. – Enable us to construct a Strategic Property Plan for you and your loved ones.  Planning is bringing the long run into the current so you are able to do one thing about it now!  This provides you with route, outcomes and extra certainty. Click here to learn more
  2. Purchaser’s company – As Australia’s most trusted consumers’ brokers we’ve been concerned in over $3.5 Billion price of transactions creating wealth for our purchasers and we will do the identical for you. Our on the bottom groups in Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane convey you years of expertise and perspective – that’s one thing cash simply can’t purchase. We’ll provide help to discover your subsequent residence or an funding grade property.  Click here to learn how we can help you.
  3. Wealth Advisory – We will offer you strategic tailor-made monetary planning and wealth recommendation. Click here to learn more about we can help you.
  4. Property Administration – Our stress free property administration providers provide help to maximise your property returns. Click here to find out why our purchasers get pleasure from a emptiness price significantly under the market common, our tenants keep a median of three years and our properties lease 10 days sooner than the market common.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here